I also wanted to thank you for placing a Zuni jar with contemporaneous paintings. What a great reminder of other art going on at the same time!
How did you choose what to display in the Life & Death exhibit? Did you work with Native people to find out what would be ok to show? For example, some kachinas are taboo. Very interesting exhibit!
Good point about the Kachinas, the Zuni and the Hopi have very different views about the secrecy of the Kachina culture.
The Hopi actually make and sell Kachinas at Indian Market, while the Zuni are much more secretive. Some of the Zuni ones we have on display were actually commissioned for the museum in 1920s in secrecy. Others were purchased from traders working in the area. However, since the days of our collecting ideas and approaches to curating from these cultures have significantly changed. Members of both Zuni and Hopi tribes have worked with the curators for this display. The curators also work closely with many Native people tribes to ensure that the exhibits are respectful of the native cultures.
I knew the modern ones were for sale. I'm fascinated by the old commissioned ones. I didn't know that was done back then.
It's actually a really interesting story, about the Zuni figures in particular. Give me a second to write out for you what it entailed.
Stewart Culin, our curator of Ethnology from 1903-1929, traveled often to the Southwest to collect for the museum. He tried really hard to get some Kachina dolls and masks over multiple visits, but the Zuni made it impossible. He was even supervised during his stay to make sure no sacred objects were purchased by him.
However, in 1904 (sorry, not the 1920s as I mentioned earlier..) Andrew Vanderwagen, a missionary who had a trading store in the Pueblo at the time, was able to secure many dolls and different masks for Culin. Vanderwagen had hired three She-we-na (Zuni) to make these objects, and had them work in a locked room in his basement.
Culin expressly stated that all the kachina dolls on view at the museum were new, and hadn't been used during any of the Kachina ceremonies. Authenticity in fact, couldn't be guaranteed, since the men were working in secrecy and under the pressure of a deadline, and the dolls were not viewed by the community for vetting. These dolls do not carry ritual paraphernalia like most dolls, and their kilts are not hemmed, so it's questionable whether they represent specific Kachina spirits or not. Though the Zuni who have visited the museum since have approved their display and have expressed that they do seem authentic.
It's part of the complexity of being a museum of such long standing, where collecting practices, understanding of culture, and respect for communities has shifted so dramatically over time. That's why our curators are so eager to work with different tribes and First Nation communities about the display and explanation of their objects.
I'm glad to hear that, thank you. Your integration of Native art in the American story is a huge contrast from some others nearby (I visited AMNH earlier this week and was pretty traumatized!). It's great to see the old and contemporary Native items together, too. Thanks so much for sharing all this with me. This app is a great resource, btw.